On Memories Of Former Homes

The market is swarming with people on Friday afternoon. Tables covered with piles of fruits, vegetables, meat, fish, eggs, bread, and household goods beckon as their owners shout their prices into the din. Feral cats dart beneath the tables, dodging people and cars to snatch scraps of food. Shoppers haggle: “Ten shekels for this? No way. I’ll give you eight.”

If you listen closely, you’ll hear Hebrew, Arabic, Russian, English, and probably more. You’ll see men with kippas and black hats. You’ll see women, including young girls, with every inch of skin covered but their hands and faces, and women with miniskirts and crop tops. You’ll see schoolchildren shopping for their families and old men and women dragging bags of groceries on their own. There will always, at any given moment, be an old lady standing at the curb and shouting at a bus driver because the bus route has changed, and the rest of the passengers are shouting to her which bus to take instead.

More than anything, you’ll notice the heat. It beats down from the sky and rises from the pavement, seeps out of buses and cars and into your body like a poison. It’s a dry heat, which may seem like a small comfort, but it makes all the difference.

Past the market stalls and down the mountain, the Mediterranean glimmers. By this time of year it’s nearly impossible to actually swim in thanks to the jellyfish, but if you swim in the bay you’ll be fine.

The hours pass and the market starts to shut down. By the time the sun is setting, the whole city has slowed nearly to a stop: buses don’t run anymore, stores have closed, and the last few stragglers are rushing through the streets to get home. As night falls, the smell of freshly-baked challah flows out of open windows along with the prayers and songs of Shabbat.

To you, this may be unfamiliar and weird and even uncomfortable; to me, it was home.


When I was 13, I returned to Israel for the first time since my family moved away seven years earlier. That trip, at the time, meant absolutely everything to me. It was a chance to rediscover my history and heritage. It was a vacation from the boredom and bullying that made up my school days. Most of all, it was an escape from the horrible new feeling–not even just a feeling, but a way of being, really–that had seeped into every little corner of my life. Six years later, I would learn to call it depression.

Those two weeks in Israel caused mood swings the likes of which I’d never experienced before (but that would become too familiar over the following nine years). I felt ecstatic to be back in what I then considered my Real Home and full of wonder at the things I was seeing and learning. Being there caused a flood of old memories to resurface and I delighted in them.

But at the same time, I balked with increasing fear and horror at the idea of returning to my miserable American existence, which I was certain I could cure only by returning to Israel after high school. (I did not, obviously, know about antidepressants.)

Although I knew I’d miss the food and the stunning beauty and the beach and all that, what I knew I’d miss the most was just that feeling that I had there, that unmistakeable thereness.

I told my mom in tears that I was terrified of forgetting what it was like to be there, and in response she told me about a trip she took to southern Russia as a teenager, a trip that grew fuzzier in her memory over time, but that she could never truly forget. Maybe the details were gone, but the essence was not and never would be.

Somewhat comforted, I tried to capture the “thereness” in any way I could. I associated it in my mind with certain smells and songs. I kept a detailed diary. I took photos. I recorded it in poems.

Ever since, I’ve been chasing that feeling.


Summer is probably the best time of the year to be in Ohio. It’s hot and muggy as hell, but everything becomes soft and beautiful in the summer. The fields of ripening corn ripple over hills left by glaciers long ago, and the streams that wind through the woods–assuming they haven’t dried up–are perfect for dipping your feet into.

My mom and I, and later my siblings once they were told enough, would often explore the paths that lead through these woods. Many of them separated different subdivisions from each other, or they were part of school grounds or parks. One such path led to a mysterious mansion far away from any other houses; another was strewn with paintballs that my little brother eagerly collected but that my sister was for some reason terrified of.

Summer in Ohio is anything but quiet. Cicadas can keep you up at night if you’re not used to them, and early in the morning you’ll be woken up by neighbors tending to their lawns more meticulously than my family ever did. Once or twice a week we’d drop whatever we were doing because we’d hear the ice cream truck coming down the street, and that was our favorite summer sound of all. (That, and the lifeguard’s whistle when breaktime ended at the pool.)

For a good twelve years or so, that’s how all my summers felt. Nowadays they’re quite different.


More wisdom from my mom: the summer before I started college, I was dating my best friend and we were about to go off to different schools. Although I’d spent the previous summer in Israel, away from my then-boyfriend, this was the first time I’d be in an indefinitely long-distance relationship and I wasn’t taking it well. His school started a month before mine did, so he was the first one to leave. My mom told me, explaining that my anguish was perfectly normal: “It’s always harder to be the one who stays.”

Maybe that’s a small part of the reason it’s so much easier now for me to love places than people. With places, I always get to be the one who leaves. Places don’t “grow out” of me and leave me; I grow out of them and leave them. People change suddenly, without warning; places usually change slowly and very predictably, if you know anything about sociology.

That’s not to say that my relationships with places are easy or simple. It took me a long time to understand that I love my town in Ohio in some way. It was painful to realize that I couldn’t stay there and still be myself. It was even more painful to come to Northwestern and realize that what I thought for five years would be a safe haven was actually rather cold and unwelcoming, and not the sort of place I would ever learn to belong in. Yet there were things I loved about it too.

When I was little I played a game with myself. It was very simple. All I did was pay careful attention to my surroundings and pretend that I was seeing them again after having been away for a very long time, perhaps because I’d been transported to a magical alternate universe and had just now found my way back (I liked fantasy novels as a kid; can you tell?). This game made me see ordinary things like my house or my backyard through an entirely new lens. I was able to make myself feel as though my boring white-bread neighborhood was the most amazing place in the world, simply by pretending that I’d been forced to leave it for a while.

Later on, that actually sort of happened. No, I didn’t get transported through a wormhole to an alternate universe; I just went back to Israel for a whole summer (the aforementioned summer). When I returned to Ohio, I instantly fell in love with it in a way I never had before. It was so green. So quiet. So comfortable. I could understand the language strangers spoke to me. How had I ever taken that for granted?

I never really lost that feeling, and I carry it with me now as I move to a place that’s almost as different from Ohio as Israel is.


Everyone whines that they hate snow, but you can feel the energy pick up on campus as the flurries turn to snowflakes that grow bigger and bigger. Just a few hours ago it was sunny and above freezing, but that’s Chicago weather for you.

As Deering Field turns from green to white, students on break from class (or maybe just skipping) show up to throw snowballs and make snowmen. Past the field, Deering Library towers imperiously like a set from Harry Potter. In fact, we’d often jokingly call it Hogwarts.

If you walk past the library and down to the lake, you’ll see the hundreds of huge rocks that line the coast. Most of them have been painted by students to celebrate friendships, relationships, student groups, or just their lives at Northwestern in general. Sometimes I see marriage proposals, sometimes I see my favorite song lyrics, sometimes I even see Russian words; I’m not sure which of those makes me happier.

Ever since I first saw the painted rocks the summer after my seventh-grade year, I knew I had to get into Northwestern and paint my own rock someday. I managed the first half of that, but, for some reason, not the second.


You might think that, as a person with depression, I tend to focus and ruminate on the negatives of things. Although I do that sometimes, I also have a remarkable ability to find the positive in just about everything. Usually this ability serves me very well; although I’m fragile during transitional periods and dislike change, once I’ve had some time to process things I’m able to adapt to just about anything. That’s because I find the good in it.

Ironically, though, when I’m depressed this turns into a sort of weakness. Like a lifesaving medicine that becomes a deadly poison in overdose, my happy memories of past homes become so potent during depression that they rob me of my ability to appreciate the present. When I’m depressed, I’m tortured by these memories, which play over and over in my mind like faded old movies that I can’t turn off. I remember the most insignificant little things: the worn-down steps to my grandma’s apartment building in Haifa, the porch swing on the deck back in Ohio, the hard and scratchy couch in my old dorm where I’d watch football games on TV in the fall, the sound of kids jumping off the diving board at the pool my family went to (still goes to; I’m just not there anymore), the snow falling around University Hall, the taste of a sudden mouthful of Mediterranean water, the slam of the door to the garage when my parents came home from work, the music of my high school marching band echoing through the muggy summer night.

I think of these things without wanting to and I hear the same cruel thought over and over: You will never feel these things again.

I have these memories, but the places they come from are lost to me forever.

Oh, sure, I could return, physically at least. I have returned. But the feelings are gone. That thereness is gone.


Another season, another (very different) campus. It’s a summer night in New York City and I’m sitting in front of Columbia’s Butler Library and crying for too many reasons to explain. Students–my peers, theoretically–walk past me in chattering groups and I wonder for the millionth time what’s wrong with me. I’m finally exactly where I wanted to be and somehow it still feels awful.

After a while I pick myself up and walk somewhat mechanically off of campus onto Broadway. The sun has just set, which in most of my previous homes would mean that things have either died down or will shortly. But here, the city is just coming to life. The restaurants around campus are still full. People are standing around in front of bars and on street corners talking. The 24-hour pharmacies and grocery stores and diners (I’m still amazed at the idea of a 24-hour anything other than Burger King or 7-Eleven) are full of customers.

The night is warm, but not hot, and I feel better.

There are, right now, over 8 million people in this city who are just like me and also not like me at all. All of them have, at some point, been as terrified and lonely as I am right now. All of them have places that they love and miss. All of them have friends that they rarely see, or might never see again. All of them have parts of their pasts that they wish they could relive, and parts of their pasts that they wish they could forget, and maybe even parts of their pasts that they wish they could both relive and forget, if only because forgetting would end that burning need to relive.

It’s hard to feel alone when I think about that.


People tell me that the new memories I’m making can replace those old ones. That the new home I’ve found makes up for the loss of my previous homes. It doesn’t, just as new friends can’t replace the ones I’ve lost. Love just doesn’t work that way.

For what it’s worth, I’m glad that I’ve moved to a place that I adore so much. I’m glad that I could live here for the rest of my life and still be learning new things about it all the time. I’m glad that I’m a just a subway ride away from sprawling parks you can get lost in and from some of the loudest, most crowded city streets I’ve ever seen, from stores that sell the food I grew up with and stores that sell food I’ve never heard of or tasted before.

But those memories continue to haunt me and I know that I have to live with them somehow.

The best I can do is to try to capture them in writing so that I don’t have to carry their weight on my own, but it seems that I can’t. At best, writing provides a facsimile, a movie-set version of landscapes that were endlessly deep and rich. They didn’t end with a painted backdrop.

Sometimes I feel like I’d give anything for just one more day to inhabit these old places, homes, selves, lives. I want to feel like I felt when I lived there. I want to feel like the person I was, even though I don’t actually want to be that person anymore.

Isn’t there any way I can come back?

Most of all, though, I don’t want to lose yet another home. But it’s too late. I made the decision to move months ago, and even if I’d chosen to stay in Chicago, it wouldn’t have been the same. College is over. Those lazy days in coffee shops and bookstores are over. Running down the hall or down the stairs to see my friends is over. I will never again feel like I felt when I did those things, and I will never again be the person who did them.

I have to keep telling myself this so that it’ll sink in, even though telling myself this feels like shit. Otherwise I’ll keep feeling like any minute now I’ll wake up back in my old apartment and realize that this whole New York thing was just a weird and kind of scary dream, and it’s time to throw on some clothes and get to class.

But the funny thing is that someday this, right now, is what I’ll miss. Someday the memories I’m making right now will have a “thereness” of their own and I will miss them just as terribly as I miss Israel and Ohio and college now. Someday I’ll look back on my first days and weeks in New York and smile and cry about them.

It is probably true that whenever I travel between these four places in the future, I will simultaneously be leaving and coming home. I’m trying to make my peace with it, as awkward as it feels.

It’s weird, isn’t it? Loving more than one person feels completely natural to me.

Loving more than one place, though, feels like betrayal.

On Memories Of Former Homes

7 thoughts on “On Memories Of Former Homes

  1. 1

    Change “Israel”/”England”
    Change “Ohio”/”Toronto”
    Change “Chicago”/”Ottawa”
    Change “NYC”/”Baden-Soellingen”
    Add “Waterloo where I have lived for the 20 years since all of that”, because I’m 20 years older.

    Otherwise…yes, exactly. Exactly. Just so.

    Beautiful writing, Miri.

  2. 2

    I understand that feeling. A few weeks ago I was back in my old hometown and went for a drive past my childhood home (which I have exceedingly fond memories of). The neighborhood has really taken a downturn… a lot of absentee landlords who don’t care, and meth has started ravaging the area… so when I saw my loved old home and there was siding missing and broken windows… I started to cry. Had to drive away before I completely broke down. The thereness was gone for me too and it was a lot harder to take than I ever thought it would be.

  3. 3

    Wish I could relate. I’d love to have that feeling of something called home. But thirteen schools across three states in twelve years helped ensure that there would not be any place I could point to with that feeling that somehow I belonged there. Relatable to me or not, however, it was a beautifully written essay. Thank you for sharing it with us.

  4. 4

    What a beautifully written entry.

    …career in activism and counseling; how about including professional writer. I haven’t read anything this well written, on any blog, in a long time (actually, anywhere on the internet)! You definitely have a gift for language.

    Oh, and praise be to Zoloft!

  5. 5

    First, this is beautiful. Never stop writing Miri.

    Second… this was a little bit disarming for me to read. I had to set it aside until I had time to read it slowly and think about it.

    I had my first episode of depression shortly after my family moved from Maryland to Indiana when I was fourteen. Before that summer when we packed up to move, I had never identified that strongly with the place I was from. I loved the water, having grown up with the bay in my backyard, but otherwise I wasn’t terribly attached to my community/town/state/etc. In fact, my family had ALMOST moved several times in the past, always for a job for my dad that he ultimately turned down because he decided at the last minute that it wasn’t worth leaving our home. And all those previous times, I’d been nervous but excited. And I thought I’d handle the actual move that way too. It would be no big deal, just a grand adventure.

    But it wasn’t like that. I don’t really know what came first… the depression or my anger and bitterness about the move. But it happened, and very quickly. I hated everything about my new home and my new life. The small drainage pond we could see from our backyard seemed to be a cruel joke, reminding me of the bay I left behind. I spent most of my time in classes staring out the window and day dreaming about my old bedroom, my old back yard. Sometimes I’d get so deep in it that when I shook it off and realized that I was actually still in Indiana, sitting through some awful class, I’d be devastated and have to hold back tears. I was sure nothing would ever be okay again until I was back there. I dreamed about growing up and buying back the old house.

    Of course, a lot of this was the depression, and after it lifted I got somewhat better adjusted to life in Indiana. But “home” has been a difficult and intense concept for me to deal with ever since. I also wrote a lot about my old house and my old life, desperate to preserve it. Lots of journal entries, lots of angsty teenage poetry. And even now, more than ten years later, memories from then are strangely intense and emotional from me.

    The dorm complex I lived in for my first two years of college was very old. Some of the large common areas had more modern heating, but the rooms had old-fashioned radiators. When you turn one of those things on for the first time of the season, they have a very unique smell that I’ve always imagined is several months worth of dust and grime burning off, but I don’t really know. The house I grew up in was built in the early twenties, and though it had been partially updated, we still had an old radiator in the kitchen, next to the corded phone on the wall. We used to sit there during phone calls with far away relatives, or when we were getting a serious talking to from one of our parents. Our radiator produced that same distinctive smell when we first turned on the heat in the fall.

    After I first turned the heater on in my college dorm, as I sat shivering and huddling next to it waiting for the warmth to come, the smell started and the memory of sitting on the radiator in my old house hit me like a ton of bricks. It so vivid. And then I was crying crouched in front of a grimy old radiator. Four goddamn years after I’d last been inside my old house.

    I have gotten attached to other places since then, including, to some degree, the Indiana house, but more so to the gifted kids boarding school I attended for two years of high school, and to some of my favorite places on and around my college’s campus. But never as strongly as I was attached to my first home. I don’t really want to, to be honest. Not right now. Right now, I am comfortable attaching to people, but my physical/geographical freedom is too important to me to really settle in someplace. In fact, I’ve moved so many times in the last few years that I’m rather nonchalant about the whole thing.

    But the experience of leaving home that first time, and the way it interacted with the rest of my life at the time and with my psychology……. that’s all still a significant part of me. Enough so that this essay just knocked me over. Thanks for sharing it with us.

  6. 6

    This post was really beautiful, and it resonates with me in many ways. Mostly, it reminds me of how I felt about Philadelphia when I moved to Atlanta. Now that I’m back to (at least near) Philadelphia, every time I go into town it feels more significant. I can never re-live my many memories of Philly, but I can be reminded of them. I try to appreciate all of the things of my life–my relationships, the various places I have lived, and the places I visit–knowing that there will be times when I look back with complicated feelings.

    There are sometimes I feel like crying, laughing, or just feeling content. No matter the specific feeling I have for a place, it does not seem to go away, even if it might change depending on my state of mind. Thanks for a wonderful read.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.