Mental Illness as a Spectator Sport

Step right up, ladies and gents, see the amazing inhuman hoarders here!

Our culture seems to have three ways of relating to people with mental illnesses–either they’re pathetic losers who need to “snap out of it”, or they’re crazies who need to be locked away (think schizophrenia in popular culture), or they’re here for our pleasure and entertainment. That last one is a relative newcomer, and that’s the one I want to write about here.

Just look at our celebrities–specifically, the ones with substance abuse problems. When it comes to them, it’s all fun and games till someone dies. While the late Amy Winehouse was still alive, blogs and magazines loved to publish photos of her visibly drunk, putting her up for public ridicule. Sure, everyone knew she could use some rehab–she sang about it herself–but there was never an ounce of compassion in how we, as a society, related to her.

And take Charlie Sheen, clearly a troubled individual. I don’t even remember how many days went by that articles making fun of him littered my Google Reader feed. With him, there isn’t even any ambiguity regarding the diagnosis, but he was still treated like a circus animal, and everyone sat back in their seats, made some popcorn, and watched.

Take TV shows like A&E’s Hoarders, Intervention, and Obsessed. These shows literally turn mental illness–and the treatment thereof–into entertainment. You can laugh as the poor OCD sufferer cries when forced to touch a gas pump nozzle with her bare hands, or gag as that creepy hoarder guy reveals his apartment full of old snack wrappers and rotting food.

I’m not saying that it’s wrong to inform people about the lives of those with mental disorders. What I’m saying is that this informing should be done in a compassionate, humanizing way, and reality TV isn’t always the best format for that. For instance, the show In Treatment, which describes a (fictional) therapist and his clients, is a far cry from the carnival sideshow-like feel of the reality shows. I’m not exactly a big fan of reality TV in general, but as a medium for educating the public about mental illness, it’s even worse than usual, because it creates an environment in which people view their fellow human beings as freaks to be gawked at, not as peers to be sympathized with. (A counselor quoted on Everyday Health calls it “exploitanment.”) This happens on virtually every reality show–think how much the people on Jersey Shore and American Idol get made fun of. The difference is that the people on Jersey Shore and American Idol (arguably) do not have a serious mental illness.

Ultimately, all media companies want to provide stuff that sells, and in the case of magazines that publish photos of drunken celebrities (with witty commentary, of course) and TV networks that produce shows putting people with mental disorders up for display, the money’s definitely talking–people love it. But the quality of mental healthcare in the U.S. will never improve while our culture continues to treat people with mental disorders as amusing distractions and not as people.

Mental Illness as a Spectator Sport

7 thoughts on “Mental Illness as a Spectator Sport

  1. 2

    I recently read that there is a new show that will come out soon called “Undateables.” It will show autistics and other kinds of supposedly “freaky” people struggling with finding a date. Talk about humiliating.

    Seriously, as if neurotypical people didn’t struggle with their personal lives as well. But it’s so much more fun to make fun of those creepy, weird autistics, right?

      1. There are several people who told me, “I really admire your husband for marrying an autistic woman.” One person told me that my husband is a hero. Seriously.

        I’m sure they will love this show.

      2. On a sort-of side note, think the stigma against autism-spectrum people just goes to show how important pretense is in our culture. A guy I met at school this past year has Asperger’s, and I actually found it really refreshing that he didn’t ever talk about dumb crap he doesn’t really care about, and if he found what I was saying to be boring, he’d interrupt me. We had a lot of great conversations because he’d just come up to me and ask me questions about my opinions on various things.

      3. Tim

        I opened this post from my RSS to ask if you people from across the ocean have such a dating show too, but seems like you unfortunately got that covered already.

        We had such a show but it ran at the same time as something just as stupid but more popular so it as thankfully cancelled. It basically involved taking people (usually men, but there were a few women) that struggle with dating for whatever reason, judging what was wrong with them and then “fixing” them.

        Yeah, it was a huge load of crap and I am happy that it is gone.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.