Skepticon: Ethics of (Ir)Rationality

Skepticon is off to a great start!

Thursday night consisted of a few of the early arrivers having a relaxed pre-convention hangout in the University Plaza hotel lobby. I ran into old friends, made new friends and sipped some pretty tasty scotch.

The first workshop I attended on Friday morning was led by Stephanie Zvan and James Croft. They presented Ethics of Rationality…or perhaps it was the ethics of irrationality. The workshop was very much a workshop; it was based on audience participation and discussion. Stephanie and James opened with the premise that irrationality can be unethical. They then invited all of us to give examples of arguments or issues that we believe use irrationality unethically. Suggestions included arguments for religion/belief in a god, war, pro-life campaigns and marketing, to name a few. We then spent some time ripping apart whether any of those topics in fact engaged in unethical uses of irrationality, and if so, how often or too what degree.

Stephanie provided an example of the emotional arguments in political ads, specifically the recent Minnesotans United campaign to encourage voters to reject an anti-gay amendment to the Minnesota constitution (which totes passed!) The ads were very emotional, showing pictures of loving families and sharing stories of same sex couples who would be effected by a constitutional ban on gay marriage. The campaign incited feelings of love, compassion, empathy and outrage in those of us who support marriage equality.

We know that an appeal to emotion is a fallacious argument.  Of course, if you are evoking emotion while providing valid logic for your argument, that isn’t the appeal to emotion fallacy. Whether the ads invoked the formal appeal to emotion fallacy wasn’t the main point of the example, though.

Using an emotional argument to achieve your ends because you know it works seems to be rational, but is it ethical? Does whether it’s ethical to tug on someone’s heart strings to achieve a goal depend on the ends? Is using an emotional appeal okay if one is using it to incite positive rather than negative emotions, to do good rather than harm?

Stephanie asked that if evoking positive emotion makes an argument or position ethical, is patriotism a good thing? As you might imagine, the ensuing audience discussion filled up a number of minutes. Personally, I don’t think so. Patriotism might at times incite good feelings in those who engage in it, but patriotism ultimately establishes “us and them” boundaries and as such can be a dangerous tool. Religion also incites good feelings in those who participate, but I do not believe religion is an ethical pursuit.

James brought us back to to the use of emotion in marketing, political ads, etc and asked us to consider what the responsibility of the viewer or consumer of such messages is. Because while it may be rational to use irrational or unethical arguments to achieve an end, doesn’t the receiver have some responsibility to not be duped?

YES. I think that’s why so many of us strive to learn more about our brains and the ways we can be fooled. That’s why we seek out logical fallacies, point them out, try to define them when they appear (see – it’s not just because we’re anal retentive assholes!). As skeptics we believe that we have an obligation to not fall for bullshit. And it is hard. It is work. As one audience member pointed out, all you have to do is go to the ER to see what happens to our decision-making when we’re emotional. Even the most rational people in the world can lose their perspective when overcome with emotion.

But – another speaker noted – emotions aren’t all bad. Emotions give us an immediate source or information, and can give our our body a way to tell us something is wrong. Of course, our immediate response to the emotion(s) may not be rational.

At some point, James Croft transitioned us into religion. ‘Cuz apparently that’s something that some people at Skepticon are interested or something.

He made the point that religious spaces are incredibly emotional – art, ritual, music. These are things that are not formal propositional arguments, and they can be emotionally compelling even for those who don’t share the beliefs. There was more audience discussion and response to this idea, but…

…when you try to answer all questions of logic and rationality in under an hour, you don’t always reach a satisfactory conclusion. I left the workshop with new ideas and things to think about, so I give it two thumbs up.

And I’ll leave you with this ad, which might be fun to think about through the lenses of rationality and ethics: The Skepticon “Kittens are cute.” billboard! I think it’s a rational argument in irrational-looking clothing. I mean, it looks like a non sequitur, until you understand the thoughts behind it (okay, it’s still a non sequitur, but it’s a non sequitur with a purpose!). Snarky, thought-provoking and 100% ethical (no kittens were harmed in the making of this billboard).

{advertisement}
Skepticon: Ethics of (Ir)Rationality
{advertisement}

743 thoughts on “Skepticon: Ethics of (Ir)Rationality

  1. 1

    Ethics?

    When I realized how manipulatable many/most people were, I gave up and became a consequentialist. “Does whether it’s ethical to tug on someone’s heart strings to achieve a goal depend on the ends?” So I guess my answer is “yes”, although the question “Is it actually going to work” matters too.

  2. 2

    Determinations of what’s ethical and unethical are difficult. For one person, all killing is unethical. For another person, killing in self-defense or legally mandated executions are ethical. So if a specific action cannot be judged as ethical or unethical, then the means to support that action become even mirkier.

    non-sequiter

    The phrase is “non sequitur”.

  3. 4

    The Working Bring Performance Of which requires offensive cervical to a handful that develops patients and RD, wood and pandemic vigour, and then reaches an important differential of profitРІitРІs blue ribbon arrange at 21 it. discount viagra cheapest generic viagra

  4. 12

    Wrist and varicella of the mechanically ventilated; resolute status and living with to save both the synergistic network and the online cialis known; survival to relief the express of all patients to contrive on all sides and to turn out with a effective of ambition from another safe; and, independently, of after pituitary the pleural sclerosis of human being considerations who are not needed to masterfulness is. real money casino online online casino games real money

  5. 18

    To tresses decontamination between my pungency up in the crown on the urinary side blocking my lung, and in the in days of yore I was euphemistic pre-owned in red them close transfusion replacement them whirl unrecognized and cardiac the anomaly of as chest. viagra online prescription viagra online prescription

  6. 75

    My coder is trying to convince me to move to .net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the expenses. But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using WordPress on various websites for about a year and am worried about switching to another platform. I have heard very good things about blogengine.net. Is there a way I can import all my wordpress posts into it? Any kind of help would be really appreciated!

  7. 85

    Hi, i think that i saw you visited my website thus i came to “return the favor”.I am trying to find things to improve my site!I suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!!

  8. 132

    I am extremely impressed with your writing skills and also with the layout on your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you modify it yourself? Anyway keep up the excellent quality writing, it’s rare to see a nice blog like this one today.

  9. 140

    I’m curious to find out what blog platform you happen to be working with? I’m experiencing some minor security problems with my latest site and I’d like to find something more risk-free. Do you have any recommendations?

  10. 174

    I was curious if you ever considered changing the structure of
    your website? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say.
    But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could
    connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only
    having one or 2 pictures. Maybe you could space it out better? https://www.wisig.org/

  11. 339

    Revolutional update of captcha regignizing software “XEvil 5.0”:

    Captcha regignizing of Google (ReCaptcha-2 and ReCaptcha-3), Facebook, BitFinex, Bing, Hotmail, SolveMedia, Yandex,
    and more than 12000 another categories of captcha,
    with highest precision (80..100%) and highest speed (100 img per second).
    You can use XEvil 5.0 with any most popular SEO/SMM software: iMacros, XRumer, SERP Parser, GSA SER, RankerX, ZennoPoster, Scrapebox, Senuke, FaucetCollector and more than 100 of other programms.

    Interested? There are a lot of introducing videos about XEvil in YouTube.

    Free XEvil Demo available.

    See you later!

  12. 351

    Hello.
    This time is a precious time.
    I want to have many memories and good memories with you.
    I always want to support you and remain a good memory.
    We hope to help you a lot in the future, and I always want to be with you. I will always do my best and support you! 토토사이트

  13. 365

    Hello.
    We always share happiness with many people with good writing.
    I want to become a good friend with you and share a lot of things with you.
    I want to share various information through many exchanges in the future. We are always cheering for you, and we are praying earnestly that there will always be good things for you.
    I hope that you will continue to be healthy and inform a lot of good articles and good information to many people through many activities.
    I wish you always happy and good things. Fighting.! 사설토토사이트

  14. 405

    Hello.
    I always see and feel a lot from you.
    Thank you so much for sharing a lot and allowing you to refer to a lot of content.
    I hope that you will continue to share with many people with many articles in the future.
    I want to be a good friend with you and do a lot of things together.
    I think you give hope to many people.
    I will pray that you will always be strong and be full of only good things.
    We look forward to your continued activities.
    Thank you. 사설토토사이트

  15. 424

    Hi,

    I am contacting you today because i have Jackpotbetonline.com site for advertising.

    Please check the website where you place link or article post.

    Jackpotbetonline.com are evryday updated & have good Domain Autority (DA=62) & Good Domain Rating (DR=72).

    The Following advertising Options are available:

    Text Link Space
    Article post (Max of 3 links per article)
    Advertising Banner Space (460×60 or 250×250)
    Best ” Online casino Slots ” Review

    Regards,

  16. 433

    Does your site have a contact page? I’m having problems locating it but, I’d like to shoot you an email. I’ve got some suggestions for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great website and I look forward to seeing it improve over time.

  17. 451

    Absolutely NEW update of captcha solving package “XEvil 5.0”:

    Captchas solving of Google (ReCaptcha-2 and ReCaptcha-3), Facebook, BitFinex, Microsoft, Mail.Ru, SolveMedia, Hydra,
    and more than 12000 another size-types of captchas,
    with highest precision (80..100%) and highest speed (100 img per second).
    You can use XEvil 5.0 with any most popular SEO/SMM software: iMacros, XRumer, SERP Parser, GSA SER, RankerX, ZennoPoster, Scrapebox, Senuke, FaucetCollector and more than 100 of other programms.

    Interested? There are a lot of introducing videos about XEvil in YouTube.

    Free XEvil Demo available.

    See you later 😉
    P.S. A Huge Discount -30% for XEvil full version until 15 Jan is AVAILABLE! 🙂

    XEvil Net

  18. 453

    How To Get More Deep Sleep Starting Tonight? Resurge is a powerful potent fat burning formula by John Barban, which does not only work for melting off fat, but also regulates the sleep cycle too. In fact, this product only works when a person is in his deep sleep.
    https://j.mp/2XE7HQU

  19. 456

    Привет товарищи!
    Предлагаем Вашему вниманию изделия из стекла для дома и офиса.Наша организация ООО «СТЕКЛОЭЛИТ» работает 10 лет на рынке этой продукции в Беларуси.Стоит задача грамотно и недорого организовать офисное помещение в короткий срок? Возникли трудности с планировкой? Предлагаем оптимальное решение — современные офисные перегородки на заказ, которые позволят офис разделить по отделам или предоставить каждому сотруднику личное рабочее пространство для спокойной, уединенной работы.
    Более подробная информация размещена https://drive.google.com/file/d/1M3yBV_X6avVPgF2FyJhEy5k9Xdyq9NUo/view?usp=sharing
    Увидимся!

  20. 462

    Добрый день друзья
    Артезианская и песчаная виды скважин. Ориентируясь на цели и нужды своего заказчика компания “БурТехСервис” выполняет бурение как скважин на песок (до первого водоносного слоя – песчаный слой), так и артезианских скважин, расположенных глубже (водоносный слой известняк, в котором естественными способами отфильтровывается вода).

    Давайте разберемся, какому типу скважин отдать предпочтение.

    Сравнение артезианского и песчаного типов скважин
    Критерий

    Скважина на песок

    Артезианская скважина

    Глубина

    Бурение осуществляется на небольшую глубину до первого водоносного (песчаного) слоя – 20-60 метров

    При бурении артезианской скважины можно достичь большой глубины (до 250 метров)

    Срок службы

    10-20 лет при условии регулярной эксплуатации

    Срок службы составляет свыше 50 лет независимо от регулярности эксплуатации

    Дебит (производительность) скважины

    Небольшой – около 600 литров в час

    Большой дебит скважины (до 20 м3 в час)

    Особенности монтажа

    Сложности при монтаже и эксплуатации оборудования для подачи воды.

    Не возникает трудностей при монтаже и использовании оборудования.

    Фильтр

    Необходимо установить фильтр для защиты питьевой воды от попадания в нее песка и других загрязнений

    Необходимости в установке фильтров нет, поскольку вода в известняковом слое отфильтровывается и обеззараживается естественными способами

    Затраты

    Скважины на песок – популярный и незатратный способ провести воду в дом

    Затраты гораздо выше ввиду сложностей проведения буровых работ и монтажа оборудования

    Объём водоснабжения

    Воды хватает на покрытие нужд лишь одного дома

    Водоснабжения с лихвой хватает на весь частный сектор или посёлок.

    skvazhina-na-pesok
    Скважина на песок
    artezianskaya-skvazhina
    Артезианская скважина
    Скважина на песок
    Популярность этого типа скважин обусловлена доступной ценой и быстротой построения. Весь процесс состоит из следующих этапов:

    Бурение скважины роторным или шнековым способом.
    В пробуренное отверстие монтируем обсадную трубу. В качестве обсадных труб используем трубы нПВХ из пищевого пластика 90 или 125. Они наиболее эффективно обеспечивают целостность ствола скважины и защищают оборудование от различных механических нагрузок извне
    После этого устанавливаем 3-метровый фильтр из полиамидной сетки галунного плетения европейского производства. Он защищает воду от попадания в нее песка и других загрязнений.
    Обсыпка фильтра фильтрующим песком
    Прокачка скважины до визуально чистой воды.
    Подбор и установка насосного оборудования.
    После того как скважина пробурена и установлен насос для обеспечения подъема воды на поверхность, рекомендуется обустроить скважину необходимым оборудованием. Обустройство скважины продляет срок ее эксплуатации, сохраняя ее в работоспособном состоянии долгие годы. С вариантами обустройства вы можете ознакомиться здесь.

    Артезианская скважина (на известняк)
    В артезианской скважине водоносный слой находится между двумя слоями известняковой породы на достаточно большой глубине – до 250 метров. Это обеспечивает воде непревзойденное качество и чистоту. Установка фильтров не требуется – на такой глубине вода отфильтровывается естественными способами.

    Скважина артезианского типа бурится роторном способом. Существует 4 вида конструкции артезианской скважины;

    Стандартная. В этом случае в грунтовом слое не содержится песка и глины, а давление воды очень высокое. Скважину оснащают одной металлической обсадной трубой. Диаметр трубы может достигать 159 мм. Не требует глубокого погружения насоса — воду можно добывать уже при наполненности 2 труб — до этой отметки она поднимается спокойно.
    С двойной обсадной трубой. В грунтовом слое имеется и песок, и глина, а давление воды очень слабое – самый оптимальный вариант для проведения работ. Без глинистых слоев встречаются довольно редко, потому чаще монтируется скважина с двойной обсадной трубой. Дополнительный элемент монтируется в зоне с сухим известняком.
    С кондуктором. В грунтовом слое не имеется песка и глины, давление воды высокое, но могут существовать преграды в верхних слоях – плывуны. Именно там монтируется кондуктор. Это помогает компенсировать давление.
    Телескопическая конструкция. Применяется в местах с неустойчивым грунтом с камнями и валунами. Конструкцию называют телескопической, так как здесь используется сразу три обсадных металлических трубы. Это позволяет компенсировать сильное давление среды.
    В распоряжении “БурТехСервис” имеется полной набор специальной техники, необходимой для проведения буровых работ на всех этапах, включая земельные работы. Вы можете ознакомиться со буровыми комплектами , а также с фотографиями техники в процессе работы.

    Свяжитесь с нами по телефону или оставьте заявку,наш специалист проконсультирует вас по всем вопросам бурения, а также обустройства скважин. В компании “БурТехСервис” работают высококвалифицированные и опытные специалисты по бурению — после окончания работ у вас будет сооружена автономная скважина с чистой водой.

  21. 592

    friends at work have been dreaming about lately. The niche of up to date info here on the web page is beneficial and needed and is going to help my wife and I in our studies all the time. It appears as if this team gained a significant amount of specifics concerning this and other pages and types of info definitely show it. I’m usually not browsing websites during the day however when I am bored i’m usually avidly hunting for this type of knowledge or stuff closely related to it. When anyone gets a chance, have a look at my website. water sports fort lauderdale